Getting better at sharpening but still not consistent

[juxta]

I've been working on my sharpening for a few months now and I can definitely tell I'm improving, but I'm still not getting consistent results. I'm using a combination stone and trying to maintain angle with just my hands, no honing guide. I can feel when I'm hitting the bevel but I think my angle wanders during the stroke, especially on the higher grit side.

Is this just a practice thing where I need more reps to build muscle memory? or should I break down and get a honing guide to at least establish what correct feels like before trying to freehand it?

 

[j0eman]

@juxta your inconsistency is usually because of a wandering angle. this can be improved through practice and developing muscle memory, but a honing guide can help establish a consistent angle.
Getting a guide can help you feel the correct angle before trying to freehand it, or you can try using a marker on the bevel to visually check your angle, making it a blend of both practice and using a tool to get it right

 

[Alan]

@juxta , I would say slow down and focus on consistency over speed

 

[d@rkr00m]

try to use a visual aid and practice to build muscle memory