I am comparing two spindle moulders: Holzstar TF190SE (230V) and Holzmann FS200S (230V).
On paper, they appear almost identical:
The only clear difference is motor power (Holzmann slightly higher).
However, I am interested in actual precision, not specifications.
Questions:
I am mainly doing joinery (hardwood, e.g. oak, lock miter joints), so repeatability and precision are critical.
Kind regards
Karsten
On paper, they appear almost identical:
- 30 mm spindle
- 4 speeds (1800–9000 rpm)
- tilting spindle (-5° to +30°)
- similar table size (~710 × 640 mm)
- similar weight (~170 kg)
The only clear difference is motor power (Holzmann slightly higher).
However, I am interested in actual precision, not specifications.
Questions:
- Has anyone measured spindle runout (TIR) on either machine (in mm)?
- Any experience with axial play or bearing stability under load?
- Does one brand show more variation between machines?
- How stable is the fence under pressure when doing joinery (e.g. lock miter)?
- Do they require significant setup/adjustment out of the box?
I am mainly doing joinery (hardwood, e.g. oak, lock miter joints), so repeatability and precision are critical.
Kind regards
Karsten
